It was a sad, sad day in the Twilight fandom. Stephenie Meyer finally
addressed the issue on the leak of her unfinished draft of her next book, Midnight Sun.
Many of the fans replied saying that they were devastated, crushed, angry and sad. The hardcore fans even vowed not reading the partial draft, that Stephenie Meyer posted on her site just so fans don't have to go around the internet and downloading it illegally, out of support for their beloved author. The hardcore fans even called those who downloaded/ read the draft as not true fans.
Many speculated who leaked the draft and even blamed the cast of the movie who Stephenie Meyer gave copies to to help them further understand the lead male character.
I couldn't help but speak out of the moral and ethical dilemma I went through before downloading the book. This was my comment in one of the top fan sites:
"To be honest, I stumbled upon the unpublished manuscript last Monday, 23 August, on a site whose membership was by invitation only (which means not just anyone can download off the site). The source said that she got it off another site and she’s not sure if it’s authentic or real.
I downloaded it out of curiosity (yes, it’s in human nature to be curious) and read it under the assumption that it wasn’t the real manuscript (and therefore, to me, it was just fan fiction that was enough to get me by).
But I also thought “What if the manuscript is real?” And so out of respect to Ms. Meyer, therefore, I vowed never to repost the link of my source(so that others won’t be able to download it). I also vowed that I will buy the book once it comes (even reserve a copy prior to the release date and line up at midnight to get it).
It was only yesterday, when Ms. Meyer addressed the issue, that I confirmed that the manuscript I got was authentic.
Ahhh, that was one instance in my life where morality and ethics came out to play.
Do I feel that I contributed to this fiasco? No, simply because I did not leak the manuscript and if I did not stumble upon the link, this issue would still explode because there were other fans who downloaded it as well out of curiosity, out of weakness, out of temptation. Had I not stumbled upon the link earlier, I would still have read the partial draft in Ms. Meyer’s site because I’m just like that. I don’t mind getting spoiled. I’m the type who reads the end of the book first. So by reading the draft, it doesn’t make me less of a true fan (unlike some fans think but hey, I respect your opinion. No bashing there, please).
Do I feel bad that I downloaded the manuscript and read it before Ms. Meyer posted the draft on her website? No, because honestly, it was beautiful- typographical errors, grammar glitches and all. Just like Alyssa, it made me look forward to the book even more. Just by reading Chapter 1 before, it made me even want this book to come out before Breaking Dawn!
Do I feel bad for Ms. Meyer? Yes, of course. My heart goes out to her. And I do hope that the love and support of her fans (and her love for Edward) inspire her to continue writing Midnight Sun.
Oh, and just my two cents about who leaked the draft. I don’t think it was anyone she gave the draft to. Most likely, someone found that particular draft lying around somewhere and scanned them. It was a careless mistake made by the person Ms. Meyer gave that particular draft to to leave it lying around. I’m guessing the person who scanned it thought he/she was doing the fandom a favor by spoiling Midnight Sun but it backlashed and now he/she is stewing in his/her guilt. Fine, that person’s identity is anonymous now but I bet her conscience won’t let her rest.
I know this is quite long but I’ve been silently lurking and I just felt I had to share my story, given the risks. Thank you to all those who read this!"
I know I sound like a lawyer but I figure, if I sounded professional, there would be less bashing. Fans of the Twilight Saga are not only supportive and protective, they are very, very rabid! :)
3 Comments:
hey cat. this is che (aka thefool). we both won two (2) Orchestra Center tickets at OAP courtesy of Anton. You got the Saturday show while I got the Friday show. I'm just taking a chance and wondering if you'd like to switch tickets. My gf can't make it on Friday. I'm willing to go out of my way to pick the tickets up if need be. Please advise. If not possible, it's ok too. Thanks so much and congrats. Please text me at 0929-6986738
hey cat. che again. ignore my previous post. :) anton switched my tickets. thanks so much!
hey you're back! i only found out through anton's blog :) my blog's on private mode na....email me your add so i can give you access: tinggayforever@yahoo.com :) nice to see you're blogging again!
Post a Comment
<< Home